7 Safest Neighborhoods In Brooklyn (2023)

Brooklyn happens to be one of the most hip and happening boroughs out of the five that comprise New York City. And if you are moving into Brooklyn then you are probably racking your brains right about now wondering which area to look for apartments in.

It is natural to be in a dilemma because, to be honest, Brooklyn has quite a number of attractive places where living will be full of amenities.

Real estate prices though, are not just dependent on amenities but also on how safe the area is. So this is a prime necessity when you go apartment hunting. The safest places to live in Brooklyn are not one but plenty but one needs to conduct thorough research before they settle in one place.

This is because some parts of Brooklyn still experience the occasional gory crimes and although the liveability of this borough has increased by leaps and bounds in the past decade, it still won’t harm to rate the neighborhoods according to their prices and subsequent amenities and safety provided.

To do this, you don’t even have to move an inch, all you have to do is open up a free crime mapping tool and enter the name of the neighborhood and the tool will give an elaborate statistic of the different kinds of crimes that occurred there in the past year.

Safest Neighborhoods In Brooklyn
Overhead View of Park in Dumbo / Renka / Bigstockphoto.com

7 Safest Neighborhoods in Brooklyn

The borough of Brooklyn is located between Manhattan and Queens and is one of the most sought-after places to settle down.

Whether you are new to New York and looking for an old hand to help you out and sort through the thousands of choices for a home or if you are a seasoned New Yorker looking to relocate to this part of NYC, this guide of the safest areas of Brooklyn has been compiled for you:

Cobble Hill

Located right adjacent to the I-278 line that connects it to the Brooklyn bridge, this place has a high livability score according to various statistics for the area.

Mostly populated by young professionals, families, and commuters, Cobble Hill is considered among the best in the safest Brooklyn neighborhoods.

This neighborhood has a total crime rate that is 33% lower than the national average and a violent crime rate that is 70% lower than the national average. Here at Cobble Hill, which happens to be safer than 87% of other cities in New York, you have a 1 in 64 chance of becoming a victim of any kind of crime.

On top of being one of the safest neighborhoods in Brooklyn, it is also one of the richest ones with a median household income of $116,500. Despite this, the rent rates are not as outrageous as one would expect.

A single-bedroom apartment may cost around $2600-2800 while a double bed may cost $4000. This is definitely a catch given that Cobble Hill has such amazing connectivity and safety.

In essence, Cobble Hill is ideal for you if you wish to live in an upscale place without blowing a hole in your finances.

Prospect Heights

This is another of those higher-end neighborhoods where the vibes are unique and artsy and feels like the place has a life of its own. Prospect Heights, which can be considered one of the safe Brooklyn neighborhoods, is quite gentrified and thriving as more and more young people and singles have been settling down here in the last few years.

Statistically, this neighborhood is very safe and has a safety score 98% higher than the national average. The crime rates over here are the lowest in all of Brooklyn. It has tons of bars and restaurants so entertainment and fun are never wanted over here. It has good connectivity to various cultural attractions around the area and is surrounded by subways and bus routes.

The population of this place mostly comprises Caribbean Americans and the average resident over is 34 years of age maybe because of the concentration of youth over here, the culture in Prospect heights is very boho and hip as well as liberal and welcoming.

The place has a vibrant nightlife and also boasts lots of green spaces. Although this neighborhood lacks good public schools, that does not seem to be a concern for the residents, most of whom are non-families and/or do not have children.

Brooklyn Heights

Brooklyn Heights is well recommended for those who want to settle in with their families. It is one of the poshest places and boasts a sufficient amount of security easily making it a safe neighborhood in Brooklyn.

Here the crime rate is 70% lower than the national average and there are almost nonviolent crimes in the area. Although one might hear of the occasional property crime such as stealing a houseplant from the front porch.

According to the latest available statistics, here you have a 1 in 145 chance of becoming a victim of any kind of crime, and Brooklyn Heights is considered safer than 80% of other cities in the United States.

The place has lots of green spaces and a beautiful view of Manhattan. The average resident over here is a family person and is engaged in some sort of business or finance-related work which is why the median household income in this place is $109,643. However, the cost of living over here is 7% higher than the national average.

The neighborhood also has a number of public and private schools and that is why more families with children tend to settle down over here and almost 47% of all residents are families. Brooklyn Heights has an acceptable number of restaurants and eateries but the nightlife over here cannot be said to be very loud, which is why it is ideal for people who love a quiet life.

Carroll Gardens

If you are a commuter to New Jersey or Manhattan then this neighborhood in Brooklyn will be perfect for you because of the easy distance between the places. Apart from that, if you want authentic Italian food in Brooklyn then this is the place for you because the neighborhood has a rich heritage of Italian immigrant settlers.

The average resident over here is either young people renting with their partner or friends or professionals who live here to be closer to their working places.

Carroll Gardens is one of the safe areas to live in Brooklyn as statistically, crime rates over here are 6% lower than the national average, while violent crime rates are even more favorable as it is 19% lower than the national average.

Here, you have a 1 in 46 chance of becoming a victim of any crime although the most outrageous crimes over here are mostly related to property disputes. The average rent over here is also quite low compared to some other neighborhoods, so it is a good choice for a place to live in Brooklyn.

Red Hook

Red Hook is an extremely safe place, to say the least. It is located on the south of Carroll Gardens and boasts a majestic view of Governor square. This neighborhood has a population of mostly black people and most of them are young professionals who rent with their partners or friends.

This place also has lots of artists and quirky people as is evident in the trendy boutiques, art galleries, and beautifully decorated eateries that abound here.

In terms of crime, Red Hook is not only a safe part of Brooklyn to live in but is unarguably one of the safest with a total crime rate 100% lower than the national average.

Here you have a 1 in 47 chance of becoming a victim of any crime and Red Hook is safer than 95% of other cities in the United States.

Despite the low crime rates, the strange thing about this place is the low median household income which is only about $28,000. This is quite low but we also have to keep in mind that most residents here are artists and young professionals so the amount makes sense.

DUMBO

More than a neighborhood, DUMBO which is short for Down Under the Manhattan Overbridge Pass, is more of an exclusive community with less than 3000 residents.

Even with such a low population, it is one of the richest communities in Brooklyn with a median household income of $160,846. More than 50% of people own the homes they live in and rent here is also a staggering 33% more than the national average. 

Despite the high cost of icing over here, the crime rates here are very low and the place boasts a safety score that is 30% more than the national average.

The thing is, although DUMBO has a very low number of residents, the place still is a major thoroughfare that millions of people pass through every day. Whatever crime occurs here can be almost always because of that.

Mapleton-Flatlands

This is the place to go for medium-income families and people who wish to live in a homely, welcoming place that is also safe. This is one of the largest Brooklyn neighborhoods with about 200,000 residents and even with that crime rates are very low over here.

Here, the total crime rate and violent crime rate are 38% and 9% lower than the national average respectively. And you have a 1 in 70 chance of becoming a crime victim in Mapleton-Flatlands, which is also safer than 75% of other cities in New York.

On a whole, the culture here is very diverse and although the black population is the largest, there are also a good number of Asian and Hispanic households over here. In essence, it is a welcoming place that is diverse and has plenty of green places and public schools along with good connectivity and safety.

Don’t miss:

Safest Neighborhoods In Boston
Safest Neighborhoods in Manhattan
Do buildings have a 13th floor
How To Get Bad Neighbors To Move

Wrapping Up

After you are done deciding on a place you like, you might want to pay a visit and knock on a few doors to get first-hand reviews from actual residents.

And as long as you live in an area that has low crime rates in its immediate vicinity, it should be good enough.

Sharing is caring!